An introduction to facial expression analysis

By Neil McKay

24.01.2018

Watch video

Our faces are one of the strongest indicators of our emotions, whether we’re laughing or crying, our emotions are there for all to see. Our faces reflect how we feel.

According to the facial feedback hypothesis , our emotions are intertwined with our facial expressions. For example, an individual who is forced to smile during a social event will gradually find the event more enjoyable.

Our facial expressions are controlled by 43 facial muscles, which themselves are controlled by 2 facial nerves.

Facial Muscles

Studying facial expression analysis

Practitioners have been fascinated with the field of facial expression analysis (FEA) for more than 100 years. In 1969 Swedish anatomist Carl-Herman Hjortsjö created the first FEA system, which, in 1978, Paul Ekman and Wallace Friesen developed into the Facial Action Coding System (FACS), further updated in 2002.

Facial Action Coding System (FACS)

FACS represents a fully standardised classification system of facial expressions based on anatomic features. It’s used by expert human coders who carefully examine face videos and describe all facial expressions as combinations of elementary components called action units (AUs).

FACS

Image Credit: Machine Perception Laboratory

Although FACS is non-intrusive, it is very laborious and expensive. It can take up to an hour and a half to classify a one-minute video.

Facial electromyography (fEMG)

Facial expressions can also be analysed with facial electromyography (fEMG), which uses electrodes attached to the face to track muscle movement.

This technique measures muscle activity by detecting and amplifying the tiny electrical impulses that are generated by muscle fibres when they contract.

It focuses mainly on two major muscle groups in the face, the corrugator supercilii group, which is associated with frowning, and the zygomaticus major muscle group, which is associated with smiling.

FeMG

Image credit: Biopac

fEMG allows measurement of very subtle facial muscle activity; although it is intrusive, which heightens respondents’ awareness of being measured.

Emotional AI

More recent developments have led to automatic facial expression analysis being carried out by computer software. Progress in computer vision and computational algorithms has made it possible to mimic the face reading skills of humans based on the tracking of subtle changes in facial features on a moment-by-moment basis.

How does emotional AI work?

Emotional AI first identifies a human face in real time or in an image or video. Computer vision algorithms identify key landmarks on the face – for example, the corners of the eyebrows, the tip of the nose, the corners of the mouth. Deep learning algorithms then analyse pixels in those regions to classify facial expressions.

Combinations of these facial expressions are then mapped to emotions.

Facial Recognition

Computer vision algorithms identify key landmarks on the face

Emotions

In psychology, an emotion is defined as a complex state of feeling that results in physical and psychological changes that influence thought and behaviour.

Psychologist Paul Ekman determined that there are six core emotions, which he termed universal emotions. They are:

  • joy (sometimes referred to as ‘happiness’) – symbolised by mouth corners raising (an obvious smile) and eyelids tightening;
  • surprise – symbolised by eyebrows arching, eyes opening wide, exposing more white, and jaw dropping slightly;
  • sadness – symbolised by mouth corners lowering, eyebrows descending to the inner corners and eyelids drooping;
  • anger – symbolised by eyebrows lowering, lips pressing firmly and eyes bulging;
  • disgust – symbolised by upper lip raising, nose bridge wrinkling and cheeks raising;
  • fear – symbolised by upper eyelids raising, eyes opening and lips stretching horizontally.

He later added a seventh emotion that is sometimes considered universal:

  • contempt (a mixture of anger and disgust) – symbolised by half of the upper lip tightening up (using what is called the risorius muscle) and often the head tilting slightly back.

These emotions can then be displayed visually in accordance with what the respondent is interacting with at that immediate time.

In this example, the in-market respondent, struggling to find a ‘red fabric sofa’ – experiences negative emotions of anger, surprise, sadness and disgust.

In this example, the respondent struggling to find how to compare his ‘favourites’ experiences emotions of anger, surprise, sadness and disgust.

Combining biometric research

A limitation of facial expression analysis is its inability to assess emotional arousal (intensity of emotion). To get both the valence (quality) of the emotional response as well as the amount of associated arousal (intensity), FEA needs to be used in conjunction with eye tracking, galvanic skin response (GSR) and electroencephalography (EEG).

Arousal vs Valance

Collecting synchronised data from multiple biometric sources adds even more to the picture as every sensor contributes a valuable aspect of emotional response you can’t get any other way.

Biometrics are redefining conversion rate optimisation (CRO)

Biometrics are redefining CRO and what it means to optimise. Those pioneering e-commerce brands that are already embracing it are gaining a distinct advantage over their competitors. By focusing on creating an emotionally enhanced customer experience they are getting more ‘new’ and ‘repeat’ customers. And even more important, they are building Customer Loyalty.

 

External sources/references:

Facial Feedback Hypothesis
https://www.affectiva.com/
Paul Ekman Group
iMotions
Carl-Herman Hjortsjo
https://www.kairos.com/

Neil McKay
Hi, I’m Neil and I’m passionate about helping organisations grow their businesses online by applying data, science and psychology. Our company Endless Gain is central to this passion. For more than 15 years, I’ve been helping businesses here in the UK, Europe and USA grow their online profits. Today’s businesses must be more scientific in how they approach business growth and that’s where we can help. In addition, our approach to conversion optimisation enables companies to maximise their marketing channel investments.

Our Clients